Bread Pudding Recipe with Cinnamon & Caramel

Cut the bread into chunks. Day-old works better — stale, not rock-hard. Three eggs, three cups milk, two sugars, cinnamon. That’s the custard. Pour it over. Let it sit. Bake it slow. The caramel goes on top, hot, and that’s bread and butter pudding done.

Why You’ll Love This Bread Pudding Recipe

Tastes like someone spent all day on it. Takes an hour. Works as dessert or breakfast — tried both, breakfast hits different when it’s still warm. The caramel sauce isn’t optional. Changes everything. Buttery, sweet, the kind of thing you’d pour on cardboard and it’d work. Cinnamon and custard smell like comfort food should smell. Not complicated. Just right. Leftovers actually improve. Not sure why — maybe the flavors settle overnight, maybe it’s just better cold with cream poured over. Either way.

What You Need for Bread and Butter Pudding

Sturdy white bread — one loaf, cut into one-inch cubes. Not sandwich bread. Something with structure. Day-old is better. Stale bread absorbs the custard instead of turning to mush.

Four eggs. Beaten hard. The yolks and whites need to combine fully or you get streaks of flavor running through it.

Three cups whole milk. Or two and a half cups milk plus half a cup of cream if you want it richer. Cream changes the texture — makes it thicker, almost like a sauce.

Half cup granulated sugar. Maybe a third cup if your bread’s already sweet. You’re tasting as you go anyway.

Half cup dark brown sugar. Could swap it for maple syrup. Haven’t tried that myself, but maple syrup makes sense here.

Vanilla extract. A teaspoon and a half. Real vanilla. The fake stuff’s obvious.

Cinnamon. A teaspoon and a half. Ground. Fresh if you have it.

Nutmeg. A quarter teaspoon, grated fresh. Not the pre-ground tin from two years ago.

Five tablespoons unsalted butter, melted. Half of it goes on top before baking. The rest is for the caramel.

For the caramel sauce: three quarters cup packed light brown sugar, three quarters cup heavy cream, five tablespoons butter, and a tiny bit of vanilla. That’s it. That’s the sauce.

How to Make Bread Pudding

Coat the baking dish — nine by thirteen — with butter or spray. Sticking is annoying. Prevention is faster than scrubbing.

Toss the bread cubes in the dish so they’re loose, not packed. You’ll pour custard over them next. Bread matters here — day-old bread soaks. Fresh bread gets soggy. Different things.

Beat the eggs in a bowl. Really beat them. Add the milk, both sugars, vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg. Whisk until it’s uniform. Pockets of unmixed custard mean uneven cooking. Don’t skip this.

Pour the custard over the bread. Use a spatula and press gently — push the bread down so it’s submerged. Let it sit. Twelve minutes is what works for me. The bread drinks the custard slowly. You want it soaked through but not falling apart.

Drizzle the five tablespoons of melted butter on top. Spread it around. This is what makes the edges get crispy. Skip it and the top stays pale. The flavor difference is noticeable.

How to Get Bread and Butter Pudding Cooked Right

Set the oven to 325 degrees. Not higher. Slow baking means the center sets without the custard cracking. Fast baking burns the top before the middle’s done.

Bake uncovered for 50 to 55 minutes. The crust should be deep golden. The center jiggles a tiny bit if you nudge the dish — that’s done. Overbaked pudding is dry pudding. You’re cooking custard, not cake. Different thing.

While it’s baking, make the caramel sauce. Medium heat. Brown sugar, heavy cream, butter in a saucepan. Stir once in a while. Listen to it bubble. After five to seven minutes it darkens and thickens. That’s when you pull it off the heat. Burned caramel tastes like burned. Not sweet anymore.

Kill the heat. Whisk in the vanilla. Taste it. It should taste buttery and sweet and balanced. Not grainy. Not harsh.

Bread Pudding Tips and Common Mistakes

The pudding comes out steaming. Pour the caramel right over the top. It soaks in immediately. The warmth matters.

Serve it warm. Cold dulls everything. If you’re saving it, refrigerate it, then reheat it gently with a splash of cream poured over. Brings the texture back.

Variations: cardamom instead of cinnamon works. Orange zest brightens it. Chopped nuts, dried fruit — both fine. Some people use brioche or challah instead of white bread. Richer bread needs less soaking time or it turns to mush. Watch it.

Custard poured unevenly means dense spots. Patience to soak it fully matters more than you think. If the crust browns too fast halfway through, cover it loosely with foil. Keeps the top from burning while the center finishes.

Keeps three days in the fridge. Freezing works but it gets watery when it thaws. Better to reheat from cold with the caramel on the side.

Bread Pudding Recipe with Cinnamon & Caramel

By Emma

Print Pin

Prep:

20 min

Cook:

50 min

Total:

1h 10min

Servings:

10 servings

Ingredients

• 1 loaf sturdy white bread, cut into 1-inch cubes
• 4 large eggs
• 3 cups whole milk (or 2 ½ cups milk plus ½ cup cream for extra richness)
• ½ cup granulated sugar (reduce to ⅓ cup if very sweet bread)
• ½ cup dark brown sugar (sub maple syrup for unique flavor)
• 1 ½ teaspoons pure vanilla extract
• 1 ½ teaspoons ground cinnamon
• ¼ teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg
• 5 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted and divided
• FOR THE CARAMEL SAUCE
• ¾ cup packed light brown sugar
• ¾ cup heavy cream (sub full-fat coconut milk if dairy-free)
• 5 tablespoons unsalted butter
• ¾ teaspoon vanilla extract

Method

1. 1 Coat a 9 x 13 baking dish lightly with nonstick spray or butter; prevents sticking, crucial for cleanup.
2. 2 Toss the bread cubes evenly in the dish; loaf choice matters here — day-old or slightly stale bread absorbs custard better and avoids sogginess.
3. 3 In a mixing bowl, beat eggs vigorously; add milk, sugars, vanilla, cinnamon, and nutmeg next. Whisk to fully combine—don’t under-mix or you’ll have pockets of flavor that aren’t evenly distributed.
4. 4 Pour custard over bread cubes. Press gently with a spatula to push bread down, letting it soak completely—ideal soaking time varies, but I let it rest 12 minutes for maximum pellucid custard absorption.
5. 5 Drizzle 5 tablespoons melted butter over soaked bread surface. This extra fat creates crispy edges and buttery richness; skip or reduce if worried about calories but flavor diminishes.
6. 6 Preheat oven to 325°F instead of higher baking heat; slower bake means custard sets without cracking, edges turn golden but not burnt. Bake uncovered for 50 to 55 minutes, or until crust is deeply golden and center just set but still jiggles slightly if nudged—overbaking dries pudding.
7. 7 While baking, create caramel sauce: In a medium saucepan over medium heat, combine brown sugar, heavy cream, and butter. Stir intermittently. Listen to bubbling sounds; when sauce thickens and darkens slightly (5 to 7 minutes), remove from heat.
8. 8 Immediately whisk in ¾ teaspoon vanilla. Taste here. Sauce should be luscious, balanced sweet and buttery—not grainy or burnt.
9. 9 Once pudding’s out, pour caramel evenly on top; sauce will glisten and soak in immediately with steamy warmth. Serve warm—cooling dulls textures; if you want leftovers, refrigerate and reheat gently with splash of cream.
10. 10 For variations, swap cinnamon with cardamom or add orange zest for brightness. Toss in chopped nuts or dried fruit. Using brioche or challah bread ups richness but adjust soaking time to prevent mushiness.
11. 11 Common pitfall: pouring custard unevenly leads to dense pockets; patience to soak fully is essential. If crust browns too fast, shield loosely with foil halfway through baking.
12. 12 Storage tip: keeps 3 days refrigerated. Can freeze but tends to get soggy once thawed; better reheated from fridge with caramel on side.

Nutritional information

Calories

685

Protein

17g

Carbs

104g

Fat

22g

Print Recipe Save to Pinterest

Frequently Asked Questions About Bread Pudding Recipe

Can I make this the night before? Yeah. Prep it through the soaking step. Cover it. Bake it the next day. The flavors settle overnight, honestly tastes a bit better. Just add ten minutes to the bake time since it’ll be cold going in.

What kind of bread works best? White bread, day-old. Brioche and challah are richer but soak faster — reduce the sitting time or it turns to mush. Sourdough’s too tangy. Stick with sturdy white or a plain enriched bread.

Can I use a different sugar? Brown sugar’s good. Maple syrup instead of the brown sugar changes it — less thick, more liquid, different flavor. Not bad. Just different.

What if the top cracks while baking? Means you baked it too hot or too long. Lower the temp next time or check it at 48 minutes instead of 50. A little jiggle in the center is fine. Cracks mean it’s overdone. Still tastes okay though.

Can I skip the caramel sauce? You can. Shouldn’t. The sauce is what makes it sing. Without it, it’s just eggy bread. With it, it’s actual dessert.

How do I reheat leftovers? Low oven, covered. Pour cream on top. Fifteen minutes at 300 degrees. Don’t nuke it or it gets rubbery. Gentle heat works better.