Cheese Tortellini Soup

I kept coming back to this cheese tortellini soup because it doesn’t need much from me. Just butter, some chopped vegetables and a package of tortellini I always have in the fridge. When the tortellini float to the top you know they’re done and that’s honestly the only trick worth remembering.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• It’s ready in 30 minutes start to finish
• You probably have most of these ingredients already sitting around
• The butter makes the vegetables taste way better than oil does, I tried both
• Tortellini floating to the surface is how you know they’re cooked through without guessing or setting a timer
• Feeds six people for under $15 if you buy store brand everything
• It reheats well the next day though the tortellini soak up more broth overnight

The Story Behind This Recipe

I made this last Tuesday after work because I had a 20-ounce package of cheese tortellini that was about to hit its date. I didn’t want to overthink dinner and I had carrots and celery that needed using up too.

The whole thing came together while I changed out of my work clothes and answered a few emails. I’ve been making easy soup recipes like this one more often lately because I’m tired of complicated dinners that dirty every pan I own.

It’s not fancy but it works and I’ll keep making it because sometimes that’s enough.

What You Need

You need 4 tablespoons of butter because it browns the vegetables differently than oil and adds a richness that chicken stock alone can’t give you. I grabbed 3 carrots and 3 celery stalks from the crisper drawer, diced them into pieces about the size of a dime. They shrink down a lot during cooking so don’t cut them too small or they’ll disappear into the broth.

One medium onion works here, yellow or white doesn’t really matter. I used yellow because that’s what I had rolling around. Three cloves of garlic get minced up, I just smash them with the flat side of my knife first to make peeling easier. Don’t use jarred garlic for this one, the fresh stuff actually smells different when it hits the hot butter.

For the liquid you need 6 cups of chicken stock. I used the kind in the carton not the cans. Low sodium is better here because you can control the salt yourself later and store-bought stock is usually salty enough already.

The star is one 20-ounce package of cheese tortellini. I keep the refrigerated kind on hand, not frozen, they cook faster and the texture is better in this easy soup recipes situation. Any brand works but I like the ones stuffed with ricotta and parmesan together.

How to Make Cheese Tortellini Soup

Get your Dutch oven or any big stockpot on the stove over medium heat. Drop in all 4 tablespoons of butter and let it melt until it’s bubbling gently with little foam on top. Once that happens throw in your diced carrots celery and onion all at once.

Stir them around every minute or so for about 10 minutes. You want them to sweat and soften, they’ll start giving off this mild sweetness and you’ll hear a light sizzle that’s not aggressive. The onions will go translucent first, then the celery softens, the carrots take the longest. Don’t rush this part or the vegetables taste raw later.

Add your minced garlic now and stir it in quickly. Let it cook for about 1 minute, you’ll smell it immediately when it’s ready, that sharp aroma that fills up your kitchen. Don’t let it turn brown or it gets bitter, I’ve done that before and it ruins the whole pot.

Pour in all 6 cups of chicken stock and crank the heat up to bring it to a hard rolling boil. You want steady bubbling across the entire surface, not just around the edges. Let it boil hard for 10 minutes which sounds like a long time but it concentrates everything and softens those base vegetables even more.

Here’s the part I love. Drop in the entire 20-ounce package of cheese tortellini and stir them around so they don’t stick to each other. Keep the boil going for about 5 minutes and just watch them. They’ll start rising to the surface one by one as they cook through and swell up with the heat. When most of them are floating that’s your sign they’re done, no timer needed.

I noticed that the tortellini on the bottom of the pot float up last, so I give it about 30 seconds after the majority float before I call it. The broth stays cloudy from the starches the pasta releases and that’s completely normal, it actually thickens the soup slightly.

Turn off the heat and ladle it into bowls right away. The tortellini will keep soaking up broth if you let it sit too long on the stove.

What I Did Wrong the First Time

I added the garlic way too early, like right when the butter melted, and it burned while the other vegetables were still cooking. Burned garlic tastes awful and bitter, it took over the whole cheese tortellini recipe and I couldn’t fix it. I had to start over with new butter and new garlic which annoyed me because I was already hungry and running late.

Now I wait until the carrots and celery are actually soft before the garlic goes in. One minute of cook time for garlic is enough, maybe 90 seconds if your heat is lower than mine.

Cheese Tortellini Soup

By Emma

Prep:

5 min

Cook:

25 min

Total:

30 min

Servings:

6 servings

Ingredients

• 4 tablespoons butter
• 3 carrots, diced
• 3 celery stalks, diced
• 1 medium onion, diced
• 3 cloves garlic, minced
• 6 cups chicken stock
• 1 (20-ounce) package cheese tortellini

Method

1. 1 Melt 4 tablespoons of butter in a large Dutch oven or stockpot over medium heat until bubbling gently. Toss in diced carrots, celery, and onion. Stir often for about 10 minutes until the veggies sweat softening while giving off a mild sweetness and a light sizzle.
2. 2 Add minced garlic and stir quickly. Let it cook for about 1 minute until fragrant but not browned. That sharp aroma signals time for broth.
3. 3 Pour in 6 cups chicken stock, raise heat to bring the pot to a hard rolling boil where you hear steady bubbling across the surface. Let it boil vigorously for 10 minutes, this concentrates flavors and softens the base veggies further.
4. 4 Drop in the entire package of cheese tortellini, stirring to keep them separate. Keep boiling for about 5 minutes. Watch the tortellini float and swell, rising to the top when cooked through. This visual cue is my favorite and foolproof indicator.
5. 5 Turn off heat and serve immediately with a ladle of broth filled with tender tortellini and softened vegetables.

Nutritional information

Calories

440

Protein

15g

Carbs

36g

Fat

23g

Print Recipe Save to Pinterest

Tips for the Best Cheese Tortellini Soup

Don’t stir the tortellini constantly once they’re in the pot. I learned this by hovering over mine the first time and they started breaking apart from all the agitation. Just give them a good initial stir to separate them then let the boiling water do its job.

The butter will start to brown slightly at the edges of your pot while the vegetables cook and that’s actually good. Those browned bits add a nutty depth to the broth later when you pour the stock in. I used to wipe them away thinking they were burned but they’re not, they’re flavor.

If your stock looks too thin after adding the tortellini soup mixture, let it boil an extra 2 minutes before serving. The pasta releases starch that thickens everything naturally and it happens fast once the tortellini start opening up in the heat.

Taste the broth right before you add the tortellini and add salt then if it needs it. Once the pasta goes in you can’t really taste the broth clearly anymore because the cheese from the filling muddies the flavor and you’ll end up oversalting.

Your vegetables should be small enough to fit on a soup spoon with a tortellini. I cut mine too big once and it was annoying to eat because I had to choose between a vegetable bite or a tortellini bite, never both together.

Serving Ideas

I put a handful of fresh spinach in the bottom of each bowl before I ladle the hot soup over it. The heat wilts it immediately and it adds color without me having to cook another ingredient.

Garlic bread on the side isn’t creative but it’s what I actually ate with this. The butter in the bread matches the butter in the soup and you need something to soak up the broth at the bottom of your bowl.

A squeeze of lemon juice right before eating brightens everything up if your stock was on the salty side. Just a small wedge per bowl, not a whole lemon or it’ll taste like lemon soup instead.

Parmesan cheese grated over the top adds more cheese to an already cheesy situation which sounds redundant but it works.

Variations

I tried adding a cup of heavy cream at the end once to make it creamy tortellini soup and it was too rich honestly. Half a cup works better and you stir it in right after you turn off the heat so it doesn’t break.

Frozen spinach works if you add it when the stock is boiling hard, before the tortellini go in. A cup of frozen spinach straight from the bag, don’t thaw it first or it gets mushy and wet.

Spicy Italian sausage cooked and crumbled into the soup turns this into a completely different meal. Brown a pound of it first, drain most of the fat, then add it with the tortellini. The fennel in the sausage changes the whole flavor profile though so only do this if you like sausage.

I swapped the cheese tortellini recipe base for spinach tortellini one time and it tasted flat because the cheese filling is what makes the broth taste fuller. The spinach ones just added more green without adding flavor depth.

FAQ

Can I use frozen tortellini instead of refrigerated? Yes but add 2 extra minutes to the cooking time. Frozen tortellini take longer to heat through and they don’t always float as reliably as the refrigerated ones do.

How do I store leftover tortellini soup? Put it in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 days. The tortellini will soak up a lot of broth overnight so it’ll be thicker the next day, almost like a pasta dish instead of soup.

Can I add more broth when reheating if it got too thick? Yeah just pour in half a cup of chicken stock or even water while you reheat it on the stove. Stir it in and let it come back to a simmer, the tortellini will release some of their absorbed liquid back into the pot.

What if I don’t have a Dutch oven? Any big pot works as long as it holds at least 8 cups of liquid comfortably. I’ve made this in a regular stockpot and a big saucepan, both worked fine.

Can I use vegetable stock instead of chicken? Sure but the soup will taste lighter and less savory. I’d add an extra tablespoon of butter to compensate for the richness you lose from chicken stock.

Do I have to peel the carrots? I don’t unless they look really dirty or the skin is tough. A good scrub under running water is usually enough and it saves time.

Why did my garlic burn even though I added it when you said to? Your heat might be higher than medium or your pan runs hot. Turn it down to medium-low right before you add the garlic and it’ll cook slower without browning.

Can I make this soup ahead of time? You can make the broth base with the vegetables ahead and refrigerate it, then add the tortellini right before serving. If you cook the tortellini in advance they get bloated and mushy sitting in liquid.

What’s the best way to dice the vegetables the same size? I cut my carrots and celery into sticks first that are about as thick as a pen, then line them up and cut across into little squares. It keeps them uniform without me having to measure anything.

My tortellini stuck together at the bottom, what did I do wrong? You didn’t stir them enough right when they went in. They’re sticky when they first hit the hot water so you need to separate them in the first 30 seconds or they clump.

Can I use jarred minced garlic if that’s all I have? I mean yeah you can but it won’t smell as good when it cooks. Fresh garlic has these sharp bright notes that jarred garlic lost weeks ago in the jar.

How do I know if my stock is low sodium or regular? Check the label, it’ll say “low sodium” or “reduced sodium” on the front. Regular stock has like 800mg of sodium per cup, low sodium is usually around 400mg.

What if my tortellini are still hard after 5 minutes? Keep boiling them and checking every minute. Some brands are thicker or have more filling and they take up to 7 minutes, just watch for them to float.

Can I freeze this soup? The broth freezes fine but the tortellini get weird and grainy when you thaw them. If you want to freeze it, freeze just the vegetable broth base and cook fresh tortellini when you reheat.

Do I need to thaw refrigerated tortellini before adding them? No they go straight from the package into the boiling broth. They’re not frozen so they don’t need thawing.

Why does my soup look cloudy? That’s the starch from the tortellini leaching into the broth while they cook. It’s normal and it actually thickens the soup slightly which I think makes it better.

Can I use beef broth instead? You could but it’ll taste really different, almost like a beef stew instead of a lighter soup. Beef broth is heavy and it’ll overpower the cheese in the tortellini.

What size Dutch oven do I need for this? Anything 5 quarts or bigger works. I use a 6-quart and it gives me enough room for the boil without stuff splashing over the sides.

My onions didn’t go translucent, they just turned brown? Your heat was too high. Medium heat should let them sweat and soften slowly, if they’re browning fast turn the burner down and add a splash of water to cool the pan.

How many tortellini are in a 20-ounce package? It depends on the brand but usually around 60 to 70 pieces. That breaks down to about 10 tortellini per serving which feels right for this soup.

Should I cut the tortellini in half? No they’re supposed to stay whole. Cutting them releases all the cheese filling into the broth and you lose the texture of biting into a stuffed pasta.

Can I add other vegetables like zucchini? Yeah but add it at the same time as the garlic because zucchini cooks fast and gets mushy if it boils for 10 minutes. Dice it small like the other vegetables.

What do I do if I accidentally added too much salt? Add a peeled halved potato to the soup and let it simmer for 10 minutes, it’ll absorb some of the salt. Fish it out before serving and taste again.

Why do some tortellini sink and some float? The ones that sink aren’t cooked yet or they have more filling that makes them heavier. Give them another minute or two and they’ll eventually float when the pasta shell softens enough.

Can I use dried tortellini from the pasta aisle? I’ve never tried it with the shelf-stable dried kind. The refrigerated ones have a softer texture that works better in soup, dried pasta might be too firm even after cooking.

How do I prevent the tortellini from overcooking? Turn off the heat as soon as most of them float. They’ll keep cooking in the residual heat of the broth for another minute or so even off the burner.

What’s the difference between cheese tortellini and cheese ravioli in this recipe? Ravioli are flat squares and tortellini are little rings, but honestly ravioli would probably work fine. They float too when they’re done so the same principle applies there.