Grilled Chicken Fajitas

I’m making these grilled chicken fajitas again because honestly they’re easier than ordering takeout and they don’t leave me feeling heavy after. Plus you can actually taste the lime and char instead of just salt.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• The marinated chicken stays moist even if you overcook it slightly
• You can prep everything in the morning and grill when you get home
• Pounding the chicken to 1/2 inch means it cooks through without drying out the edges
• Indirect heat on the grill gives you that smoky flavor without the burnt spots I used to get
• The sautéed peppers work just as well in a skillet if it’s raining
• 270 calories per serving means I can load up on toppings without guilt

The Story Behind This Recipe

I started making fajitas at home last year when I got tired of restaurant versions that were either too salty or arrived at the table already cold. My first few tries were a mess because I’d blast the chicken over high heat and wonder why it was charred outside and raw in the middle. Then I read somewhere about indirect grilling for chicken and it clicked. Last Tuesday I tested this version after work using fajita seasoning I already had in the pantry and it took me maybe 30 minutes start to finish. The chicken hit 165°F right when the peppers finished and I didn’t have to coordinate anything fancy.

What You Need

You’ll need fajita seasoning which I just grabbed from the spice aisle at Kroger. Any brand works as long as it has cumin and chili powder in the first few ingredients. Mix that with lime juice and vegetable oil to make the marinade — I used canola because that’s what I had but any neutral oil does the job. The lime juice matters more than you’d think because it loosens up the chicken fibers while you’re waiting.

Grab chicken breasts and plan to spend two minutes pounding them down to 1/2 inch with a meat tenderizer or the bottom of a heavy pan. If you skip this the thick parts stay raw while the thin edges turn into jerky. For the vegetables I used one red and one yellow bell pepper plus a medium yellow onion, all sliced into strips about 1/4 inch wide. Don’t go thinner or they’ll turn to mush in the skillet.

You’ll also want tortillas for serving — I used flour but corn works if that’s your thing. Keep fresh lime wedges around because hitting the finished fajitas with more lime right before you eat them wakes everything up. Then whatever toppings you want, I did sour cream and shredded cheese but that’s not part of the actual recipe.

How to Make Grilled Chicken Fajitas

Start by whisking your fajita seasoning with lime juice and vegetable oil in a medium bowl until it looks uniform. Set that marinade to the side while you deal with the chicken. Take your chicken breasts and pound them with a meat tenderizer until they’re about 1/2 inch thick all over — I put mine between two sheets of plastic wrap so chicken bits don’t fly everywhere. Drop the pounded chicken into the marinade, cover the bowl and stick it in the fridge for anywhere from 1 to 12 hours. I did 4 hours because that’s when I got home from work.

When you’re ready to cook, heat your grill to medium-high and make sure the grates are clean and lightly oiled so the marinated chicken doesn’t glue itself down. Pull the chicken out of the marinade and let the excess drip off, then toss the leftover liquid. Place the chicken on the grill but over indirect heat — that means not directly over the flames, which is the whole trick here.

Cook each side for about 7 to 8 minutes, flipping every 2 to 3 minutes to keep it from charring. I noticed the chicken starts to firm up around minute 5 and the juices begin running clear instead of pink. Use a thermometer and don’t pull it until it hits 165°F in the thickest part. Once it’s done let the pieces rest for 5 minutes on a cutting board — I almost skipped this once and the juices just ran everywhere when I sliced it.

While the chicken rests, slice it thinly against the grain. You’ll see the muscle fibers running one direction, cut perpendicular to those. Keep it somewhere warm or just leave it on the board.

For the vegetables I did mine in a skillet because it was already dark outside. Warm your skillet over medium heat, add vegetable oil and dump in your sliced bell peppers and onions. They’ll start crackling pretty quickly. Stir them every minute or so for 10 to 12 minutes until they’re soft and glossy but not falling apart. When they’re done, toss them with more fajita seasoning and a squeeze of fresh lime juice — this is where the sautéed peppers get their brightness instead of just tasting like cooked vegetables.

If you’re grilling the vegetables instead, toss them in vegetable oil first and load them into a grill basket. Put the basket over the grill and stir every 2 to 3 minutes so they cook evenly. You want them soft with a slight snap left and maybe some faint grill marks on the edges. Pull them off and hit them with fajita seasoning and lime juice right away.

To serve, lay out warm tortillas and pile on the sliced chicken and the cooked vegetables. Add whatever toppings you’re into. The contrast of the smoky meat and the tangy peppers is really what makes this work.

What I Did Wrong the First Time

I marinated the chicken for like 20 minutes because I was impatient and it tasted fine but not noticeably better than unseasoned chicken. The lime juice and fajita seasoning need at least an hour to actually do anything, and when I retested it last Tuesday with the full 4 hours the difference was obvious. The meat had this tangy depth all the way through instead of just on the surface. Also I used to leave the chicken breasts their original thickness and just grill them longer which meant dry edges and a raw center every time. Pounding them flat fixed that completely.

Grilled Chicken Fajitas

By Emma

Prep:

5 min

Cook:

25 min

Total:

30 min

Servings:

4 servings

Ingredients

• Fajita seasoning
• Lime juice
• Vegetable oil
• Chicken breasts, pounded to 1/2 inch thickness
• Bell peppers, sliced
• Onion, sliced
• Tortillas
• Fresh lime wedges
• Fajita toppings of choice

Method

1. 1 Whisk fajita seasoning, lime juice, and vegetable oil in a medium bowl until blended. Set this marinade aside.
2. 2 Take chicken breasts and pound them evenly with a meat tenderizer until about 1/2 inch thick. Submerge the chicken in the marinade, cover, and refrigerate anywhere from 1 up to 12 hours to infuse flavor and tenderize.
3. 3 Heat the grill to medium-high, then make sure the grates are clean and lightly oiled to prevent sticking.
4. 4 Pull the chicken from the marinade, discard the excess liquid. Place the chicken on the grill but off direct flames (indirect heat). You'll notice the sizzle is more subtle here. Cook each side for about 7 to 8 minutes, flipping every 2 to 3 minutes to avoid charring. Use a thermometer to confirm the chicken reaches 165°F. The meat will firm up noticeably; juices should run clear. Once done, set the pieces to rest for 5 minutes to retain moisture.
5. 5 While the chicken rests, slice it thinly against the grain for tenderness. Keep it warm.
6. 6 To handle the vegetables indoors, warm a skillet over medium heat and pour in vegetable oil. Add sliced bell peppers and onions. You’ll hear gentle crackles as they soften over 10 to 12 minutes. Stir throughout so they cook evenly. Once tender and glossy, toss vegetables with fajita seasoning and a squeeze of fresh lime juice for brightness.
7. 7 If grilling the vegetables, toss them in vegetable oil and load them in a grill basket. Place over the grill, stirring every 2 to 3 minutes. You want the peppers and onions to get soft but retain a slight snap, their edges caramelizing with faint grill marks. Remove and season with fajita spice and lime juice immediately.
8. 8 To assemble, lay down warm tortillas, layer on sliced grilled chicken and the cooked vegetables. Add any toppings you prefer — the contrast of seasoned meat, crisp-tender vegetables, and fresh lime is essential.
9. 9 If you’ve worked through these steps, come back to share your tweaks or how the balance of smoky chicken and tangy vegetables hit your palate.

Nutritional information

Calories

270

Protein

30g

Carbs

14g

Fat

8g

Print Recipe Save to Pinterest

Tips for the Best Grilled Chicken Fajitas

Don’t skip oiling your grill grates right before you put the marinated chicken down because the sugar in the fajita seasoning wants to stick and tear the surface when you flip. I learned this when I had to scrape half my dinner off the grates.

If your chicken breasts are uneven after pounding, fold the thinner tail end under itself and secure it with a toothpick so the whole piece cooks at the same rate. Pull the toothpick out before slicing.

The resting time isn’t optional even though 5 minutes feels long when you’re hungry. I cut into the chicken early once and watched a puddle of juice spread across my board instead of staying in the meat where it belongs.

When you’re slicing the cooked chicken, angle your knife slightly instead of cutting straight down. You’ll get wider strips that look better piled on a tortilla and they hold up to the sautéed peppers without shredding.

Serving Ideas

I put out a row of small bowls with cilantro, pickled jalapeños, and crumbled queso fresco because the acidity cuts through the richness of the chicken. Sometimes I’ll warm black beans with a bit of cumin and serve them on the side for people who want more substance.

Leftover fajita filling works over rice the next day if you don’t want another tortilla situation. I’ve also chopped it up and thrown it into scrambled eggs for breakfast which sounds weird but the lime juice wakes you up better than coffee.

Variations

You can swap the chicken for flank steak but slice it thin before marinating and cut your grill time to about 4 minutes per side because steak doesn’t need to hit 165°F. The texture is chewier but some people prefer that.

Shrimp works if you marinate them for only 30 minutes max because the lime juice will start cooking them if you go longer. Grill them for 2 minutes per side and pull them fast or they’ll turn rubbery.

I tried this with portobello mushrooms once for a friend who doesn’t eat meat and they soaked up the marinade too much and got slimy. If you’re doing mushrooms just toss them in oil and fajita seasoning right before grilling instead of marinating them.

Adding a sliced jalapeño to the pepper mix works but seed it first unless you want actual heat instead of just fajita seasoning heat.

FAQ

Can I use chicken thighs instead of breasts?
Yes but boneless skinless thighs don’t need pounding and they cook faster, maybe 5 to 6 minutes per side. They’re more forgiving if you overcook them slightly because the fat content keeps them moist.

What if I don’t have a meat tenderizer?
Use the bottom of a heavy skillet or a rolling pin. Just put the chicken between plastic wrap or in a zip-top bag first so you’re not cleaning raw chicken off your countertop.

How long can the chicken sit in the marinade?
Anywhere from 1 to 12 hours works. I did 4 hours and it was noticeably better than the 20 minutes I tried before, but I wouldn’t go past 12 because the lime juice starts breaking down the texture too much.

Can I make this without a grill?
Cook the chicken in a grill pan or regular skillet over medium heat for the same amount of time, flipping every few minutes. You won’t get the smoky flavor but the fajita seasoning still carries it.

What’s indirect heat on a grill?
Light only one side of your grill or push all the coals to one side, then put the chicken on the opposite side where there’s no flame directly underneath. The heat circulates around the meat instead of blasting it from below.

Do I have to rest the chicken or can I slice it right away?
You can slice it immediately but the juices will run out onto your cutting board instead of staying inside the meat. 5 minutes makes a real difference in how moist each bite tastes.

Can I prep the vegetables ahead of time?
Slice them in the morning and keep them in the fridge in a container. They’ll release a bit of moisture sitting there but just drain that off before cooking and they’ll be fine.

What if my chicken isn’t hitting 165°F after 8 minutes per side?
Your grill’s running cooler than mine or your chicken’s thicker than 1/2 inch. Just keep flipping it every few minutes until the thermometer reads 165°F in the thickest part, it’ll get there.

Can I use bottled lime juice instead of fresh?
It works in the marinade because you’re using it for acidity not flavor, but use fresh lime wedges for the final squeeze over the finished fajitas or it tastes flat.

How do I know when the sautéed peppers are done?
They’ll look glossy and soft but still hold their shape when you stir them. If they’re starting to fall apart or turn mushy you’ve gone too far.

What kind of fajita seasoning should I buy?
Any brand that lists cumin and chili powder in the first few ingredients. I used the Kroger store brand and it was fine, don’t overthink it.

Can I marinate the vegetables too?
Don’t do this, they’ll get soggy and won’t brown properly when you cook them. Just toss them in oil right before they go in the skillet or grill basket.

Why do I need to cut the chicken against the grain?
The grain is the direction the muscle fibers run. Cutting across them shortens the fibers so each bite is more tender instead of chewy.

How do I keep the tortillas warm?
Wrap them in foil and stick them on the edge of the grill for a minute or two, or microwave them wrapped in a damp paper towel for 20 seconds.

Can I use corn tortillas instead of flour?
They work but they’re more fragile and tend to crack if you overfill them. Warm them longer than flour tortillas so they’re pliable.

What if I don’t have a grill basket for the vegetables?
Thread them onto skewers or just cook them in a skillet inside. The grill basket’s convenient but not required.

How do I store leftovers?
Keep the chicken and vegetables in separate containers in the fridge for up to 3 days. Reheat them in a skillet over medium heat for a few minutes, don’t microwave them or the chicken gets rubbery.

Can I freeze the marinated chicken?
Put the raw chicken in the marinade in a freezer bag and freeze it for up to 3 months. Thaw it in the fridge overnight and it’ll marinate while it defrosts.

Why did my chicken dry out even though I pounded it flat?
You probably cooked it over direct heat instead of indirect, or you left it on too long past 165°F. Chicken breasts dry out fast once they hit that temp.

Do I really need to discard the marinade after the chicken comes out?
Yes because it’s touched raw chicken and you can’t safely reuse it. I know it feels wasteful but that’s the rule.

Can I make this spicier?
Add cayenne to the fajita seasoning or throw sliced jalapeños in with the peppers. The base recipe isn’t hot, just flavorful from the cumin and chili powder.