Honey Marinated Grilled Steak

I made this last Tuesday after work and honestly the honey thing sounded weird until I tasted it. The vinegar cuts through everything so you don’t end up with that sticky-sweet mess you’d expect. I used two 11-ounce steaks because that’s what I had and the honey marinated grilled steak turned out better than the fancy restaurant version I tried last month.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• The honey caramelizes into these dark crusty spots that taste almost burnt but in a good way
• You can marinate it for 4 hours or leave it overnight and both work fine
• Double bagging the marinade means you can actually flip the bags around in your fridge without leaking honey all over the bottom shelf
• It’s one of those easy steak recipes where the marinade does most of the work
• The vinegar mellows out after sitting for a while and you get this tangy bite that makes you want another piece
• You only need a few ingredients and most of them you probably already have

The Story Behind This Recipe

My sister told me about marinating steak in honey after she came back from some farmer’s market demo. I thought she was making it up because honey on meat sounded like something you’d do by accident not on purpose. But I had steaks thawing and nothing else planned so I tried it on a Tuesday night.

The first time I didn’t massage the honey into the vinegar enough and ended up with clumps of honey stuck to one side. Now I really work it in with my fingers through the bag until everything looks even. The grilled steak marinade smells sharp and sweet at the same time when you open the bag after marinating and that’s how you know it worked.

What You Need

You need two steaks that weigh about 10 to 12 ounces each. I grabbed mine from the butcher counter and they were closer to 11 ounces but it doesn’t really matter as long as they’re thick enough to not overcook in seconds. Trim off any big chunks of fat before you marinate because those pieces just turn rubbery on the grill and nobody wants to chew through that.

Honey is the main thing here and you’ll need enough to coat both steaks with a thin layer. I didn’t measure it the first time and just squeezed until it looked right. Vinegar is what keeps this from turning into candy on a plate so don’t skip it. The recipe doesn’t give exact amounts for either one but I used maybe three tablespoons of honey and two of vinegar for my two steaks and it worked.

You’ll need two large airtight plastic bags and you’re going to double bag them. I know it sounds wasteful but the first time I didn’t double bag I had honey vinegar marinade all over my vegetable drawer and it took forever to clean. The other marinade ingredients aren’t listed out here but I’m assuming you’ve got salt and pepper and maybe garlic or soy sauce or whatever else you like on honey steak.

How to Make Honey Marinated Grilled Steak

First thing is trimming those big fat pieces off the edges of your steaks. I use kitchen scissors because it’s faster than a knife and I don’t have to worry about the steak sliding around on the cutting board. Put each trimmed steak into its own plastic bag and then put that bag inside another one so you’ve got a double layer.

Now dump in your honey and vinegar and whatever other marinade stuff you’re using. Here’s the part I messed up the first time so pay attention. You have to actually massage everything through the bag with your fingers until the honey completely dissolves into the vinegar. If you don’t do this you’ll get honey globs stuck to one part of the steak and vinegar pooling on the other side. I spent a good two minutes squishing it all around until it looked smooth and even through the plastic.

Seal the bags tight and throw them in the fridge. 4 hours minimum but I left mine for about 20 hours because I marinated them Tuesday morning before work. The vinegar really does mellow out with time and you get this tangy flavor that doesn’t make your mouth pucker. I flipped the bags over once when I got home just to make sure everything stayed coated but I don’t think it made much difference.

When you’re ready to cook get your grill screaming hot. I’m talking high heat until you can’t hold your hand over it for more than a second. If you’re stuck using a broiler instead put the rack on the second slot from the top and crack the oven door open a bit or your kitchen will fill with smoke. Run your fan on high because honey drippings hitting hot metal create a lot of smoke fast.

Pull the steaks out of the marinade and let the excess drip off for a second. When you lay them on the grill you’ll hear that immediate sizzle and smell the honey starting to burn in a good way. Don’t move them around just let them sit there for 4 to 6 minutes depending on how thick they are. Mine were about an inch and a half so I did 5 minutes. Flip them with tongs not a fork because you don’t want to poke holes that let the juice out.

Another 4 to 6 minutes on the second side and then pull them off. I noticed the honey creates these dark almost-black crusty spots where the sugar caramelized against the grill grates and those bits taste better than the rest of the steak honestly. Let them rest on a plate for at least 5 minutes uncovered. I know it’s hard to wait but if you cut into them right away all the juice runs out onto the plate instead of staying in the meat.

Slice thin against the grain when you’re ready to serve. The outside should be dark brown with sticky patches and the inside should be that warm pink color that means medium rare.

What I Did Wrong the First Time

I didn’t let the honey dissolve properly in the vinegar before I sealed the bags. I just dumped everything in and figured it would mix itself during the marinating time. It didn’t and I ended up with straight honey coating one side of each steak which turned into a burnt sticky mess on the grill while the other side barely had any flavor. Now I spend the extra two minutes really working the marinade together through the bag until I can’t see any thick honey streaks anymore. It makes such a difference I can’t believe I almost gave up on this grilled steak marinade recipe after that first disaster.

Honey Marinated Grilled Steak

By Emma

Prep:

10 min

Cook:

12 min

Total:

22 min

Servings:

4 servings

Ingredients

• 2 large airtight plastic bags, double bagged
• 2 (about 10-12 ounces each) steaks, trimmed of large fat pieces
• Honey, amount as per original unspecified
• Vinegar, amount as per original unspecified
• Other marinade ingredients, unspecified

Method

1. 1 Trim all visible large fat from the steaks and place the meat into two large airtight plastic bags that are double-bagged for safety.
2. 2 Add honey, vinegar, and the remaining marinade ingredients into the bags. Use your fingers to massage everything thoroughly into the steak, paying attention to dissolve the honey fully in the vinegar. This step is essential to get an even coating.
3. 3 Place the sealed bags in the refrigerator to marinate. Four hours is the minimum, but I recommend closer to 24 hours if you want deeper flavor penetration. I’ve found the vinegar mellows and ushers a nice bite with time.
4. 4 When ready, fire up your grill on high. You want the surface roaring hot to get a strong sear immediately. If you don’t have a grill, position your broiler rack on the second highest slot, keep the oven door cracked, and run a ventilation fan to manage smoke.
5. 5 Lay the steak on the searing heat. You’ll hear a sharp sizzle as the sugars in the honey begin to caramelize. Grill for about 4 to 6 minutes, then flip carefully using tongs. Covered grills help trap heat and smoke, lifting complexity in the steak’s crust.
6. 6 After a second 4 to 6-minute interval, remove the steak from heat. Let it rest uncovered for at least five minutes. Resting allows the juices to redistribute rather than spill out when slicing.
7. 7 Slice the steak thinly against the grain for maximum tenderness. You’ll notice the surface turns deep brown with sticky caramel spots where honey met direct heat. The interior should be warm rosy pink for a true medium rare.

Nutritional information

Calories

280

Protein

25g

Carbs

6g

Fat

18g

Print Recipe Save to Pinterest

Tips for the Best Honey Marinated Grilled Steak

Watch the grill temperature like it’s about to burn your house down because honey hits that line between caramelized and scorched faster than regular marinades. I keep a spray bottle of water nearby to tame any flare-ups when the honey drips hit the flames.

If your steaks are thicker than an inch and a half bump your cooking time to 6 minutes per side or you’ll end up with a charred outside and raw middle. The honey creates a crust that makes it hard to tell what’s happening inside so press the center with your finger and if it feels like the fleshy part of your palm below your thumb it’s medium rare.

Don’t wipe off the marinade completely before grilling because those sticky bits clinging to the surface are what turn into the crusty caramelized spots everyone fights over. I learned that the second time I made this when I tried to be neat and patted everything dry with paper towels.

Room temperature matters more with this honey steak than regular grilled meat. I pull the bags out of the fridge 30 minutes before cooking and leave them on the counter so the center isn’t ice cold when it hits the heat.

Serving Ideas

I slice it thin and pile it on toasted bread with arugula that wilts a little from the warm meat. The peppery greens cut through the sweet honey coating better than lettuce ever could.

Sometimes I serve it over plain white rice with the resting juices poured on top because the rice soaks up that honey vinegar mixture and turns into something way better than plain starch. My brother adds a fried egg on top of his portion which sounds weird but the runny yolk mixes with the marinade and I get why he does it now.

Grilled vegetables on the side don’t really work because everything tastes like honey smoke. I stick with a cold cucumber salad or pickled onions that reset your palate between bites.

Variations

You can swap red wine vinegar for regular white and it adds this deeper almost fruity thing that works with the honey. I tried balsamic once and it was too sweet even with the vinegar tang so I don’t recommend that.

Adding soy sauce to the marinade turns it into this Asian-ish flavor that my roommate loved but then it’s not really the same recipe anymore. Maybe a tablespoon mixed in with the honey and vinegar if you want to try it.

Chicken thighs work with this grilled steak marinade if you can’t do beef but you need to cook them longer obviously. 8 minutes per side and check that the inside hits 165°F or you’ll make someone sick. The honey burns faster on chicken skin so watch it closer.

I tried this with pork chops and they turned out dry because pork needs different timing. Skip that variation unless you really know what you’re doing with pork.

FAQ

Can I use a different type of vinegar for the marinade? White vinegar works best because it’s sharp enough to cut the honey without adding other flavors. Apple cider vinegar is fine if that’s what you have but it adds a slight fruity taste that changes the profile a bit.

How do I know when the honey is fully dissolved in the vinegar? You shouldn’t see any thick streaks or globs of honey when you look through the bag. It should look smooth and even like a thin syrup coating the meat.

What if I don’t have time to marinate for 4 hours? Don’t bother making this recipe then because the honey needs time to break down the surface of the meat and the vinegar needs time to mellow. 2 hours won’t do anything and you’ll just have sticky raw-tasting steak.

Can I cook this in a pan instead of on the grill? Yeah but open every window first and turn your fan on high because the honey smoke will set off your alarm. Use a cast iron pan on medium-high and don’t move the steak around once it hits the surface.

Why does my honey clump up in the cold marinade? Honey gets thick when it’s cold so massage it through the bag right after you add it before the fridge makes it stiff. If you forgot just leave the bag on the counter for 10 minutes and work it around again.

How thin should I slice the finished steak? Maybe a quarter inch thick so you get some of that caramelized crust in every bite. If you slice it too thin it falls apart and if you leave it too thick it’s hard to chew through.

Can I reuse the marinade as a sauce? No because it had raw meat sitting in it for hours and heating it up doesn’t make it safe enough to risk. Just make a fresh batch if you want extra sauce on the side.

What’s the best way to store leftovers? Wrap them tight in foil or put them in a container with a lid and they’ll last 3 days in the fridge. The honey coating gets a little sticky and weird when it’s cold but it still tastes fine.

How do I reheat leftover honey steak without drying it out? Low heat in a covered pan with a splash of water is the only way I’ve found that works. Microwave turns it into rubber and oven drying happens fast with the thin honey crust.

My steak turned out too sweet what did I do wrong? You used too much honey or not enough vinegar in the marinade. Go heavier on the vinegar next time until it smells sharp and tangy not like candy.

Can I marinate the steak for longer than 24 hours? I wouldn’t go past 30 hours because the vinegar starts breaking down the meat texture and it gets mushy. Overnight is the sweet spot for this easy steak recipes method.

What happens if I skip the double bagging step? You’ll probably have honey leaking all over your fridge shelf and it’s a pain to clean. One bag isn’t strong enough to hold the weight of the steak plus the liquid without developing a weak spot.

Do I need to flip the bags while marinating? I flip mine once halfway through just to make sure both sides get equal time sitting in the marinade pool but it’s not make-or-break. The massaging at the start matters way more.

Can I add garlic to this marinade? Sure but mince it really fine or it won’t distribute and you’ll get burnt garlic bits on the grill. I sometimes smash a clove and throw it in the bag but fish it out before cooking.

Why is my steak tough after following the timing exactly? You either got a bad cut of meat or you didn’t slice against the grain. Check which direction the muscle fibers run and cut perpendicular to those lines or it’ll be chewy no matter what you do.

How hot should my grill actually be? Hot enough that you pull your hand back after one second of holding it over the grates. If you can keep it there for 3 seconds it’s not ready yet.